LIFE INSURANCE
The typical donor :
- Has outgrown the need for the insurance protection.
- Has paid into the policy for several years.
- Wants to insure completion of a significant gift.
- Uses the gift of insurance as part of an overall financial
plan.
Gift features and benefits :
- Immediate income tax deduction available to 50% of adjusted
gross income.
- Flexibility in completing various giving plans.
When you first bought a life insurance policy, you had a purpose
in mind. It was probably to help ensure the financial stability
of your family should something happen to you or your spouse.
Have your circumstances changed since then?
Life insurance can be a tool with many purposes. For example,
it can provide liquidity for paying taxes and other expenses at
death. But, believe it or not, some of the most satisfying uses
for life insurance policies are connected with charitable giving!
If you have a life insurance policy you no longer need, you might
contribute it to a charitable cause in which you believe. Purchasing
a new policy and naming the Foundation as beneficiary is another
possibility. This often makes a significant future gift feasible
and affordable, especially for younger donors.
Perhaps you are considering a sizable bequest to the Foundation,
provided your family's future inheritance is not affected. Life
insurance can play a part in meeting this goal, too, by replacing
for your heirs the amount donated.
This versatility of life insurance makes revisiting its uses
a good idea, and that's what this information will help you do.
Indirect Use of Insurance for Wealth Replacement
In recent years, probably the greatest increase in using life
insurance in philanthropic plans has been to replace for heirs
of an estate a value being given, by one means or another, to
a charitable organization like the Foundation.
A significant outright charitable gift might reduce the projected
value of inheritances for family members. However, depending on
the age, health and marginal income tax rate of the donor(s),
income tax savings from use of the charitable deduction can be
enough to purchase life insurance, whose death benefits equal
the value of the gift.
Example: Joan makes a charitable gift of a building
that has appreciated in value since she acquired it long ago.
She knows that, among other benefits, this allows her estate
to realize greater tax savings than if she had bequeathed the
building to her children. (She might also have sold the building,
but then she would have been forced to pay capital gains tax.)
She then purchases life insurance for the benefit of her children,
an expense that she would have paid anyway in taxes, had it
not been for the charitable deduction she received for her gift
to us. Instead of receiving a building, her children will receive
cash from the insurance policy-and all of this happens outside
the probate process.
If your projected estate is taxable, ownership of life insurance
by others (which also keeps death benefits out of the probated,
taxable estate) might also be considered. It's even possible to
make annual gifts of the premium amounts to the beneficiary/policy
owner and utilize your gift tax exclusions.
Gift of an Existing Policy
You may own an insurance policy that has a substantial cash surrender
value, yet the original purpose for the protection no longer applies.
The policy might have been purchased initially to provide financial
security for a spouse now deceased, to educate children now grown
or for liquidity to pay death taxes when liquid assets were in
short supply. This policy can be a sort of hidden asset, available
to be used for your philanthropic purposes.
If you choose to name the Foundation as the beneficiary of a
policy that is not paid up and also assign all incidents of ownership
of the policy to us, several good things happen. You receive an
immediate income tax charitable deduction for the "interpolated
terminal reserve" value of the policy. This is an updated
cash surrender value, a figure available from the insurer.
If you itemize deductions on your tax return, your actual income
tax savings depends on your marginal tax rate. A person who does
not normally itemize may find the additional charitable deduction
boosts his or her total itemized deductions above the standard
deduction.
For a paid-up policy, the deduction is the cost of replacing
the coverage with a comparable policy. In either situation, the
tax deduction cannot be greater than your net investment in the
policy (total premiums paid less any dividends received). The
charitable deduction is reduced by any outstanding balance of
a policy loan, which may also be considered additional taxable
income.
When death benefits under the policy are removed from a taxable
estate, there may be a future estate tax savings if your estate
would have otherwise been subject to tax.
If premiums on the policy are still payable, there are two options
to be considered. You may stipulate that the assignment of ownership
of the policy at its current value is the total charitable gift,
immediately available for our use. In that case, we might surrender
the policy for cash. Or we might decide to accept an amount of
paid-up insurance. In either case, you are relieved of the obligation
to make further premium payments.
However, an alternative may be even more attractive. The policy
can remain in force so that the larger, original face amount will
become your gift. You pledge to make unrestricted gifts at least
annually, which we will use to pay the premiums. The gifts are
deductible, and the policy is thereby kept in force with pretax
instead of after-tax dollars for a lower actual cost.
A further potential advantage is to make annual gifts in the
form of marketable capital gains property otherwise to be sold,
such as appreciated stock. Avoidance of the capital gains tax
is a second tax savings, not possible when paying premiums directly
to the insurer.
Payments of the premiums directly to the company, instead of
comparable gifts to BCF, are considered to be gifts "for
the use of" instead of "to" us. If made in cash,
the gifts are deductible only up to 30 percent of adjusted gross
income for the year, rather than up to a 50 percent annual limitation.
Use of Beneficiary Clause as a Revocable
Gift Arrangement
Other options are available if you would rather retain ownership
of a policy as an asset for your own financial security or that
of others. They include:
- naming the Foundation as the only or a partial primary beneficiary
of the policy, with the right to change the beneficiary clause
as owner of the policy;
- naming the Foundation as the contingent successor beneficiary,
receiving the death benefits only if a named individual beneficiary
predeceases you;
- creating a separate trust named to receive death benefits,
with trust terms providing first for financial support of one
or more named individuals for specific terms of years or for
life, after which the trust terminates and its assets pass to
the Foundation;
- naming the Foundation as the residual beneficiary of an annuity
settlement option available under some policies.
These plans do not produce a current income tax charitable contributions
deduction, but they can provide the satisfaction of knowing we
will receive some benefits if certain events take place and the
arrangement is left unchanged. Any amounts payable to us at your
death will not be subject to federal estate tax.
New Policy for Future Charitable Gifts
Many of our friends and regular donors who would like to make
a significant future gift to the Foundation at a relatively low
cost can do so through a new life insurance policy. With increasing
longevity, older persons can now purchase insurance at more affordable
premium costs than were possible in the past. Retired individuals
enjoying a surprisingly high standard of living can use some annual
discretionary income to perpetuate their support of our work,
without depleting their financial reserves or reducing the projected
inheritances of family members.
In most states, you can enter into a new insurance contract with
a qualified charitable organization such as ours as both the beneficiary
and owner of the policy. Gifts to the Foundation to cover premiums
are deductible for those who itemize and can be in the form of
capital gain property for a second tax savings.
Greater leverage is possible when two donors, usually wife and
husband, purchase a two-life, second-to-die policy. With two lifetimes
before payment of benefits, a desired future gift to us may be
obtained for substantially fewer premium dollars. These policies
are available even if one spouse is not insurable and are generally
more economical than a policy only on the insurable spouse.
A type of insurance sometimes used by charitable donors is a
policy for which a specific number of years of premium payments
is projected-but not guaranteed-after which the premium obligation
"vanishes." It should be kept in mind that the premium
requirement may continue for a longer period, or even vanish and
then reappear, if the policy cannot generate the assumed internal
return required to keep the policy in force.
Covering premium costs with annual gifts to us for an extra year
or two will increase values and lessen the possibility of renewed
premium payments or a reduced paid-up amount of benefits. Policies
that are not so interest-sensitive should be considered as an
alternative.
What About Term Insurance?
Term insurance, such as coverage by a group policy through your
employer, has no cash value, so assigning ownership would have
no tax advantage.
When term coverage is provided by your employer, the cost attributable
to any coverage in excess of $50,000 may be included in your taxable
income. However, if we are the sole beneficiary under the policy,
such cost is not included in your taxable income, nor will benefits
be part of your estate.
Term insurance can be used to guarantee the payment of a substantial
pledge of gifts to us payable over a period of years, without
potentially obligating your estate. The term life insurance policy
on you, the donor, can be reduced annually as installments are
paid on the pledge, with the policy dropped when the gift is complete.
Creating an Irrevocable Life Insurance
Trust
At the beginning of this article, we discussed the purchase of
life insurance as a means of replacing for your heirs the value
of a gift to us. We covered situations in which you assign the
beneficiary as owner of the policy. For larger amounts and multiple
heirs, an irrevocable life insurance trust (also called a wealth
replacement trust) may be preferable as owner of the policy, typically
with a bank trust department or trust institution as trustee.
An insurance wealth replacement trust can work well in conjunction
with a charitable remainder trust. When you establish a charitable
remainder trust, you fund it with assets that will provide you
(or another beneficiary) income for life, and then we receive
the remainder. Besides the initial income tax deduction for funding
the trust and the resulting tax savings, your income from reinvested
trust assets is typically improved, and often it's a way to avoid
capital gains tax liability. These savings free money for contributions
to the trust to pay insurance premium costs.
When the trust ends, its assets pass to the Foundation, or to
more than one charitable organization in accordance with your
wishes, without being subject to tax. The life insurance death
benefits pass to heirs from the wealth replacement trust untaxed,
having previously been transferred as annual gifts to heirs covered
by gift tax exclusions, use of credits or reduced gift tax payments.
To avoid a federal gift tax on contributions to the trust to
cover premium costs, the insurance beneficiaries can be given
a temporary right to withdraw each contribution for their own
direct use. These "Crummey powers" (named after a court
case) qualify the transfers as present interests that can utilize
annual federal gift tax exclusions. While it would thwart the
estate plan if the heirs exercised those powers, their right to
withdraw may not be restricted orally or in writing.
Find Out More
At this level of family and philanthropic distributions, it is
especially critical to have a skilled planning team with expertise
in finance, law, taxes and insurance. The benefit of the best
advice possible is well worth the cost.